Subject: [NEXTEL-1] Comdex Puts Wi-Fi Weaknesses on Display

From: Marcel <[email-masked]>
Date: Sat, 23 Nov 2002 15:10:08 -0500

http://www.80211-planet.com/columns/article.php/1546141

------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ---------------------~-->
·FREE Health Insurance Quotes-eHealthInsurance.com
http://us.click.yahoo.com/1.voSB/RnFFAA/46VHAA/61FxlB/TM
---------------------------------------------------------------------~->

Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ 

Search

Search internet.com

News |
Reviews |
Insights |
Tutorials |
HotSpots |
Forums |
Events |
Products |

Glossary |
About

Subscribe Now!

802.11-Planet.com's Weekly Newsletter

html *
text

More Free Newsletters

802.11 Glossary

Find an 802.11 Term

802 is a registered trademark of the Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers, Inc. ( IEEE ). 802.11 Planet is not affiliated with the IEEE

Find a Hotspot by City

AMF O'Hare
Addison
Akron
Albuquerque
Alexandria
Allen
Anaheim
Andover
Annapolis
Ardsley
Arlington
Arlington Heights
Astoria
Atherton
Atlanta
Aurora
Austin
Bakersfield
Baltimore
Basking Ridge
Baton Rouge
Bayside
Beachwood
Bedford
Bedminster
Bellaire
Bellevue
Belmont
Benicia
Berkeley
Beverly Hills
Birmingham
Boca Raton
Boston
Bothell
Boulder
Brea
Bridgewater
Bronx
Bronxville
Brookfield
Brooklyn
Broomfield
Buffalo
Buffalo Grove
Burbank
Burlingame
Burlington
Cambridge
Campbell
Canton
Carefree
Carlsbad
Carmel
Carnation
Carrollton
Cartersville
Castle Rock
Cathedral City
Cedar Falls
Chandler
Chantilly
Chappaqua
Charlotte
Chatsworth
Chelsea
Chicago
Cincinnati
Claremore
Clearwater Beach
Cleveland
Cocoa Beach
College Point
Colleyville
Colorado Springs
Columbia
Columbus
Concord
Coppell
Corte Madera
Costa Mesa
Cupertino
Dallas
Daly City
Denver
Detroit
Dublin
Dupont
Durham
East Elmhurst
East Syracuse
Eatontown
Edmonds
El Cerrito
El Paso
El Segundo
Encinitas
Englewood
Enumclaw
Everett
Fairfax
Farmington
Federal Way
Flower Mound
Flushing
Forest Hills
Fort Lauderdale
Fort Mitchell
Fort Walton Beach
Fort Washington
Fort Worth
Fremont
Frisco
Gaithersburg
Galveston
Garland
Gastonia
Gig Harbor
Gilroy
Gloucester
Grand Prairie
Grand Rapids
Grapevine
Greensboro
Greensburg
Greenville
Hauppauge
Heber City
Herndon
Hershey
Holly Springs
Honolulu
Houston
Howard Beach
Hudson
Humble
Hurst
Independence
Indianapolis
Iowa City
Irving
Issaquah
Itasca
Jackson
Jacksonville
Jamaica
Jonesboro
Kahului
Kalamazoo
Kansas City
Katy
Keene
Keller
Kenner
Kent
Key Biscayne
Key Largo
Key West
Kihei
King of Prussia
Kirkland
Knoxville
Lacey
Lafayette
Laguna Beach
Lahaina
Lakewood
Larchmont
Larkspur
Las Vegas
Leesburg
Lexington
Linthicum Heights
Livermore
Long Beach
Longwood
Los Altos
Los Angeles
Los Gatos
Louisville
Lynden
Lynnwood
Madison
Malvern
Maple Valley
Marco Island
Marietta
Marina del Rey
Martinsville
Marysville
Mason
Mc Kinney
Melbourne
Melville
Menlo Park
Mercer Island
Mesa
Mesquite
Miami
Miami Beach
Milford
Mill Valley
Millbrae
Milpitas
Milwaukee
Minneapolis
Missouri City
Modesto
Monroe
Monrovia
Monticello
Morgan Hill
Morristown
Mount Kisco
Mount Laurel
Mount Vernon
Mountain View
Myrtle Beach
Naperville
Nashville
Natural Bridge
New Hartford
New Orleans
New York
Newark
Newhall
Newport Beach
Newport News
Norfolk
Norristown
North Bend
North Billerica
North Richland Hills
North Salt Lake
Norwalk
Novato
Novi
Nyack
Oak Harbor
Oakland
Ocean City
Oklahoma City
Olympia
Olympic Valley
Ontario
Orlando
Pacifica
Palm Beach
Palo Alto
Paradise Valley
Park City
Parkersburg
Parsippany
Pasadena
Peachtree City
Pebble Beach
Petaluma
Philadelphia
Phoenix
Piscataway
Pismo Beach
Pittsburgh
Plano
Pleasanton
Pocatello
Pocono Manor
Pompano Beach
Port Orchard
Port Townsend
Poulsbo
Princeton
Progreso
Puyallup
Raleigh
Rancho Cordova
Rawlins
Reading
Redmond
Redondo Beach
Redwood City
Rehoboth Beach
Renton
Revere
Richardson
Richmond
Roanoke
Rochester
Rockwall
Romulus
Round Rock
Sacramento
Safety Harbor
Saginaw
Saint Louis
Saint Paul
Salisbury
Salt Lake City
San Anselmo
San Antonio
San Bruno
San Carlos
San Diego
San Francisco
San Jose
San Leandro
San Marcos
San Mateo
San Rafael
Sanibel
Santa Ana
Santa Barbara
Santa Clara
Santa Cruz
Santa Fe
Santa Maria
Santa Monica
Saratoga
Sausalito
Scarsdale
Schaumburg
Schenectady
Schiller Park
Scottsdale
Seattle
Sedona
Shawnee Mission
Silverdale
Simi Valley
Sioux Falls
Somerset
Somerville
South Haven
South Lake Tahoe
South San Francisco
Southlake
Spanaway
Spring
Springfield
Stanford
Stanwood
Staten Island
Sterling
Suffern
Sugar Land
Sumner
Sunnyvale
Swanton
Tacoma
Tallahassee
Tampa
Tempe
Toledo
Torrance
Tracy
Trumbull
Tucson
Ukiah
Vandalia
Vienna
Virginia Beach
Walnut Creek
Waltham
Washington
Wayne
Webster
West Harrison
West Hollywood
Westborough
Whippany
Wichita
Wilmington
Windsor Locks
Woburn
Wood Dale
Woodinville
Woodland Hills
Worcester
Yorktown Heights

Find a Hotspot by State

Alabama
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
District of Columbia
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Missouri
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
Ohio
Oklahoma
Pennsylvania
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming

internet.com wirelesss

• 80211 HotSpots

• allNetDevices

• Pocket PC Wire

• M-CommerceTimes

• Palm Boulevard

• PDAStreet

• Psion Place

• ThinkMobile

• Visor Village

• Pocket PC City

• WirelessAdWatch

• WirelessAuthority

internet.commerce

Be a Commerce Partner

CRM Software

Find a Consultant

Anti-Virus Software

Comparison Shopping

Free BIOS Analysis

Promote Your Website

Register Domains

Internet Jobs

Submit Your Site

Tech Magazines - FREE

internet.com

Internet News

Internet Investing

Internet Technology

Windows Internet Tech.

Linux/Open Source

Web Developer

ECommerce/ Marketing

ISP Resources

ASP Resources

Wireless Internet

Downloads

Internet Resources

Internet Lists

International

EarthWeb

Career Resources

Search internet.com

Advertise

Corporate Info

Newsletters

E-mail Offers

• Santa Clara, CA,

December 3-5, 2002

• Boston, MA,
June 25-27, 2003

<SCRIPT language='JavaScript1.1' SRC="http://ad.doubleclick.net/adj/N2614.80211planet.com/B959348.6;abr=!ie;sz=125x600;ord=2002.11.23.20.08.58?">
</SCRIPT>
<NOSCRIPT>
<A HREF="http://ad.doubleclick.net/jump/N2614.80211planet.com/B959348.6;abr=!ie4;abr=!ie5;sz=125x600;ord=2002.11.23.20.08.58?">
<IMG SRC="http://ad.doubleclick.net/ad/N2614.80211planet.com/B959348.6;abr=!ie4;abr=!ie5;sz=125x600;ord=2002.11.23.20.08.58?" BORDER=0 WIDTH=125 HEIGHT=600 ALT="Alt Text">Alt Text</A>
</NOSCRIPT>

RELATED ARTICLES

Wi-Fi from the Desert

TI Goes Multimode

Identifying Access Point Installation Locations

Comdex Puts Wi-Fi Weaknesses on Display

By Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols

Remember the early days of cell phones? When you could hope
you'd make a connection at any major business hotel or conference center, but
you couldn't be sure? Fast forward to Fall Comdex 2002 in Las Vegas and welcome
to the current state of public Wi-Fi LANs.

While only a shadow of its former self, Comdex has a wireless
focus this year and you'd expect the show, or indeed a city such as Las Vegas
that hosts other high-tech trade shows, as the Consumer Electronics Show (CES),
to have good Wi-Fi.

You'd be wrong.

Although resellers and integrators have long made bringing
Wi-Fi to hotels and conference centers a priority, few of the hotels of the
gambling center of the universe have WLAN installed. Indeed, by my count only
the Four Seasons, with WayPort and Boingo and Embassy Suites with WayPort are
setup for the Wi-Fi business traveler.

On the other hand, based on the experiences of Wi-Fi users
at the Las Vegas Convention Center (LVCC), conventional 802.11b Wi-Fi may not
be up to the challenge of dozens to hundreds of simultaneous users. Symbol Technologies put up five public Hotspots
in the LVCC, which could handle up to 300 concurrent connections. While some
of the users were able to connect some of the time, none of the users were able
to connect all of the time.

Public Wi-Fi Woes

When they worked, the Symbol networks worked extremely well.
But, when they didn't, it wasn't pretty.

The problems, based on discussions with Symbol technicians
on-site, my own troubleshooting of friends and colleagues with Wi-Fi fits, and
network analysis, came from poorly set-up Wi-Fi connections. These problems
can be summed up that many people's wireless rigs work fine -- if they never
leave their home or office Hotspot -- but they fail in roaming situations.

For all that people talk about the joys of roaming with their
Wi-Fi equipped laptops, the reality seems to be that about 30% of the Comdex
users weren't using Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol (DHCP) (define)
properly for roaming. For example, many users had Domain Name Service (DNS)
addresses and gateway hand-coded into their TCP/IP settings. Sometimes they
were able to connect, sometimes they weren't. And, a few, weren't set up to
use DHCP at all and that put a quick end to their roaming plans until their
systems were reconfigured.

It must also be said that many wireless users aren't the
least bit savvy about their equipment. I saw several cases where explicit instructions
to set the Service Set Identifier (SSID) (define) to 'Symbol' were
ignored. The users couldn't understand why they needed to change from 'ad hoc'
to 'infrastructure' mode to properly connect with the Symbol access points.
I also saw at least one case of someone complaining loudly to a Symbol help
desk team member that his 5GHz 802.11a card wasn't connecting. Well,
duh!

Many systems, including mine, had trouble locking on to a
given access point in an environment where Windows XP's SiteSurvey sometimes
showed as many as 8 access point, not to mention, laptops and PDAs in ad hoc
mode, offering their services. Like a sheep set between two loads of hay, some
systems were unable to latch on properly onto any access point in this environment.
Others showed such confusing error messages. The operating system wireless monitoring
would show no signal while the NIC's monitoring program showed connections with
both excellent link quality and signal strength.

Another problem was equipment compatibility. While almost
everyone's 802.11b Wi-Fi NICs were eventually able to connect with the Symbol
access points, there could be no question that the Symbol cards -- provided
free to Comdex users -- consistently worked better. My own D-Link AirPlus
DWL-650+ ran like a champ... when it connected. Getting it connected often
took several tries.

Part of the reason for that problem is that 802.11b only
has, for practical purposes, three channels (channels 1, 6, and 11 in the US.)
that you can use without causing interference between access points. This, combined
with the fact that all users are competing for the same 11Mbps of total bandwidth,
made getting even enough access to try to log into Symbol's network an adventure.

The simple truth is that no matter how many access points
you have, 802.11b doesn't have enough channels or available bandwidth to handle
more than perhaps two or three dozens active users at a given time. Of course,
in most situations that won't be a problem since most of the time, network administrators
are unlikely to fit that many users into an access point's range. But, if you're
setting up a trade show, coffee shop or classroom where big crowds are a real
possibility, 802.11g and 802.11a's larger numbers of channel and available bandwidth
starts to look a lot more attractive in the long run.

Beyond the Setup

Symbol, to make its network as accessible as possible, didn't
use Wired Equivalent Privacy (WEP). They did, of course, remind people that
they should use a virtual private network (VPN) if they wanted to have some
security for their online messages. Based on a quick scan of network traffic,
most people didn't.

Another real world problem is that a quick, off-the-cuff
survey of users found only about 20% of them were running ZoneAlarm, Norton Personal Firewall, or
any other kind of personal firewall.. That's a big mistake.

Some people might think no one's going to peek over their
wireless LAN shoulder. They're wrong.

Inside of an hour I saw 30 different attacks on my laptop.
Most of them were trival -- attempts to ping my system -- but there were numerous
attempts to access my hard drive via NetBIOS calls. While the great majority
of these attacks came from the Internet at large -- almost certainly from script
kiddies randomly looking for vulnerable systems to mess around with -- others
were from IP addresses within the Symbol LAN. Clearly, some of our fellow wireless
users were trying to pry into their neighbor's machines.

The moral of the story is clear. If you're going to be traveling
and using Wi-Fi, you must install and use some kind of personal firewall. Otherwise,
the person sitting next to you at Starbucks may walk out with a half-cup of
coffee and your personal files.

Problems and all, Symbol did an excellent job of providing
a massive wireless LAN to Comdex attendees. At the same time though, in so doing,
they showed how 802.11b is reaching a bit beyond its grasp in such deployments
and how both the technology, and its users still need to make improvements before
they can safely make the most of the technology.

Want to do a quick deployment of public access Wi-Fi but need some help??

Join us at the 802.11 Planet Conference
& Expo, Dec. 3-5 in Santa Clara, CA. One
of our sessions will cover

Hardware & Back-End Systems for Instant Hotspots.

November 21, 2002

RELATED ARTICLES

Wi-Fi from the Desert

TI Goes Multimode

Identifying Access Point Installation Locations

Copyright 2002 Jupitermedia Corporation All Rights Reserved.

Legal Notices,  Licensing, Reprints, & Permissions,  Privacy Policy.