Subject: Issue 42 - Siva's comments

From: "Susan Hares" <[email-masked]>
Date: Thu, 20 Feb 2003 13:29:42 -0500

Tom and Siva:

Here's the comments from Siva on issue 42.
I'll send comments next.

siva's comments.

=============

++ Issue 42 ++ 
Issue 
    I am unclear as to what is the way to proceed here. Is there consensus
that a NOTIFICATION message does need to be sent ?

++ Issue 42 ++ 

> The issue is what if Connect state occurs and there is not
> a TCP connection.  Should an OPEN with wrong version
> be accepted?  If the Open Delay flag is off, the connection
> state should not be getting an Open.  The "D" action below
> works for "open delay flag off".
>
> The "y" action you suggest can occur if the open delay
> timer is on.
>
> If this is the issue, please confirm.

> We could say: if open delay flag is on -> y action
>                   if open delay flag is off -> D action

  Yes, this is the issue, and the text you have suggested looks good.

  If this is OK, can we close the issue ?

Sivanand
([email-masked])