Subject: [multimob] PMIPv6 base solution draft - tunnel convergence

From: Behcet Sarikaya <[email-masked]>
Date: Wed, 5 May 2010 12:12:02 -0700 (PDT)

Hi Thomas, all,
In Appendix C Comparative Evaluation of Different Approaches
I was thinking that the main issue is so-called "tunnel convergence". If you remember, we discussed this offline way back in January 2010.
Tunnel convergence  
occurs when different MNs 
connected to the same MAG belong to different LMA. Then if they 
subscribe to the same multicast group, multicast data from several 
LMAs are replicated at the MAG to MNs and thus MN receives duplicate multicast data.
Can you please clarify why the tunnel convergence is not happening in your draft? 
 
I think we need to resolve this issue clearly.
 
Thx.
 
Behcet