Subject: [regext] Comment on draft-lozano-ietf-eppext-registrar-expiration-date-01

From: Klaus Malorny <[email-masked]>
Date: Wed, 27 Jul 2016 16:46:26 +0200

Hi Gustavo,

I have also comment on your draft:

Does it make sense to apply the extension to the transfer command and query? The 
unspoken principle until now seemed to me to be that the transfer command does 
not carry any "advance" settings for the domain once transferred to the new 
registrar. This is not the case for the core data, like contacts or name 
servers, nor with the common extensions -- for example, the DNSSEC extension RFC 
5910. In most cases, the gaining registrar will issue an update command to the 
registry right after the successful transfer anyway, so there is typically no 
extra step necessary. The only exception so far -- if you will -- is the 
extension period in the transfer command.

As such, I would like to suggest to stick with the principle and to remove the 
extension from the transfer command and query.

Regards,

Klaus