Subject: [Capwap] Message type and message elements

From: "David T. Perkins" <[email-masked]>
Date: Wed, 7 Jun 2006 13:50:14 -0700 (PDT)

HI,

I created a list sorted by the section number of the
message element showing the section number of the
message type where it is used. I created this from
a list of message type (and used message elements).
The two lists follow. Is this information correct?
(That is, are there no message elements listed
where they shouldn't be, and are there no missing
message elements where they should be?)
(Note 1: I had to add leading zeros to sort the
list in the proper order.)

(Note 2: message types 5.3 and 5.4 are not included)

(Note 3: I'm creating a "sheet cheat" that describes
all of the message types (operations). It is a summary
of the sections describing the message types. I have
found that it would be really handy if the sections
put in a standard place the state(s) in which the
message could be sent, and the direction of the message.
Right now, I have to dig for this info.
Here is an example from my cheat sheet.
  "(6.1)Join Request (Join state) (WTP->AC)"
Also, it's a little strange that the code for
the message types is in a table in section 4.3.1.1
(and not in the section describing the message),
but descriptions of the message elements specifies
the message element ID.) 

Message type and included message element List
Type	Element
5.1	4.4.19
5.1	4.4.34
5.1	4.4.36
5.1	4.4.38
5.1	4.4.39
5.2	4.4.1
5.2	4.4.4
5.2	4.4.40
5.2	4.4.41
6.1	4.4.26
6.1	4.4.30
6.1	4.4.34
6.1	4.4.37
6.1	4.4.42
6.1	4.4.39
6.2	4.4.29
6.2	4.4.2
6.2	4.4.3
6.2	4.4.30
7.1	none
7.2	none
8.2	4.4.4
8.2	4.4.5
8.2	4.4.28
8.2	4.4.31
8.2	4.4.33
8.2	4.4.44
8.2	4.4.43
8.2	11.10.2
8.2	11.10.6
8.2	11.10.8
8.2	11.10.13
8.2	11.10.14
8.2	11.10.18
8.2	11.10.19
8.2	11.10.24
8.3	4.4.2
8.3	4.4.3
8.3	4.4.10
8.3	4.4.15
8.3	4.4.22
8.3	4.4.35
8.3	11.10.2
8.3	11.10.4
8.3	11.10.6
8.3	11.10.8
8.3	11.10.13
8.3	11.10.14
8.3	11.10.15
8.3	11.10.18
8.3	11.10.22
8.3	11.10.24
8.4	4.4.2
8.4	4.4.3
8.4	4.4.5
8.4	4.4.6
8.4	4.4.7
8.4	4.4.9
8.4	4.4.10
8.4	4.4.11
8.4	4.4.15
8.4	4.4.16
8.4	4.4.18
8.4	4.4.22
8.4	4.4.26
8.4	4.4.28
8.4	4.4.31
8.4	4.4.35
8.4	4.4.42
8.4	11.10.2
8.4	11.10.4
8.4	11.10.6
8.4	11.10.8
8.4	11.10.10
8.4	11.10.13
8.4	11.10.14
8.4	11.10.15
8.4	11.10.18
8.4	11.10.22
8.4	11.10.24
8.5	4.4.29
8.6	4.4.11
8.7	none
8.8	none
9.1	4.4.23
9.1	4.4.24
9.1	4.4.25
9.2	none
9.3	none
9.4	none
9.5	4.4.14
9.5	4.4.20
9.5	4.4.21
9.5	11.10.9
9.5	11.10.16
9.5	11.10.23
9.6	none
9.7	4.4.13
9.7	4.4.12
9.8	none
10.1	4.4.8
10.1	4.4.17
10.1	11.10.11
10.1	11.10.12
10.1	11.10.20
10.1	11.10.25
10.2	4.4.29
11.7.1	11.10.1
11.7.1	11.10.5
11.7.1	11.10.21
11.7.1	11.10.7
11.7.2	11.10.3

List sorted by message element section
Type	Element
07.01	none
07.02	none
08.07	none
08.08	none
09.02	none
09.03	none
09.04	none
09.06	none
09.07	none
05.02	04.04.01
06.02	04.04.02
08.03	04.04.02
08.04	04.04.02
06.02	04.04.03
08.03	04.04.03
08.04	04.04.03
05.02	04.04.04
08.02	04.04.04
08.02	04.04.05
08.04	04.04.05
08.04	04.04.06
08.04	04.04.07
10.01	04.04.08
08.04	04.04.09
08.03	04.04.10
08.04	04.04.10
08.04	04.04.11
08.06	04.04.11
09.07	04.04.12
09.07	04.04.13
09.05	04.04.14
08.03	04.04.15
08.04	04.04.15
08.04	04.04.16
10.01	04.04.17
08.04	04.04.18
05.01	04.04.19
09.05	04.04.20
09.05	04.04.21
08.03	04.04.22
08.04	04.04.22
09.01	04.04.23
09.01	04.04.24
09.01	04.04.25
06.01	04.04.26
08.04	04.04.26
08.02	04.04.28
08.04	04.04.28
10.02	04.04.29
06.02	04.04.29
08.05	04.04.29
06.01	04.04.30
06.02	04.04.30
08.02	04.04.31
08.04	04.04.31
08.02	04.04.33
05.01	04.04.34
06.01	04.04.34
08.03	04.04.35
08.04	04.04.35
05.01	04.04.36
06.01	04.04.37
05.01	04.04.38
05.01	04.04.39
06.01	04.04.39
05.02	04.04.40
05.02	04.04.41
06.01	04.04.42
08.04	04.04.42
08.02	04.04.43
08.02	04.04.44
11.07.01	11.10.01
08.02	11.10.02
08.03	11.10.02
08.04	11.10.02
11.07.02	11.10.03
08.03	11.10.04
08.04	11.10.04
11.07.01	11.10.05
08.02	11.10.06
08.03	11.10.06
08.04	11.10.06
11.07.01	11.10.07
08.02	11.10.08
08.03	11.10.08
08.04	11.10.08
09.05	11.10.09
08.04	11.10.10
10.01	11.10.11
10.01	11.10.12
08.02	11.10.13
08.03	11.10.13
08.04	11.10.13
08.02	11.10.14
08.03	11.10.14
08.04	11.10.14
08.03	11.10.15
08.04	11.10.15
09.05	11.10.16
08.02	11.10.18
08.03	11.10.18
08.04	11.10.18
08.02	11.10.19
10.01	11.10.20
11.07.01	11.10.21
08.03	11.10.22
08.04	11.10.22
09.05	11.10.23
08.02	11.10.24
08.03	11.10.24
08.04	11.10.24
10.01	11.10.25

Regards,
/david t. perkins

_________________________________________________________________
To unsubscribe or modify your subscription options, please visit:
http://lists.frascone.com/mailman/listinfo/capwap

Archives: http://lists.frascone.com/pipermail/capwap