Subject: 3:219 INFO....Mirrored Registry

From: "Jim Fleming" <[email-masked]>
Date: Tue, 20 Aug 2002 19:07:34 -0500

http://www.fitug.de/atlarge-panel/0208/msg00282.html
From: "Richard Henderson" <[email-masked]>

"ICANN awarded Afilias the .info registry in the face of considerable
competition from other applicants with strong cases..."
=====

You seem to be missing some other points which may explain what you are seeing.

1. .INFO is in the Proof-of-Concept 32-bit DNS development stage.

2. ICANN did not "award" .INFO, ICANN recommended to the U.S. Government to
point to the .INFO TLD servers of one company vs. another. The U.S. Government did
that and seems to have recently changed to a different company. Note below[1], the various
.INFO TLD Clusters in the Proof-of-Concept testing phase.

3. .INFO is at the leading edge with a "Mirrored Registry" arrangement, similar to what .ORG will have.
http://www1.ietf.org/mail-archive/ietf/Current/msg17281.html

4. The 128-bit DNS services for .INFO will use some address space obtained via IN-ADDR.INFO,
which is registered in BOTH of the 32-bit DNS Proof-of-Concept Registries.

5. Despite claims about Afilias being involved with .INFO, note below, no mention of Afilias.
Also note that some of the lowest price Registrars, are not ICANN "accredited".
http://www.thepricedomain.com/index.php?domainlist=info
...will .ORG follow the same path ?...and be run by companies never mentioned in the bidding...

6. Eventually, a stable collection of [SLD].INFO owners will emerge. They can work together to
select (vote?) the vendor to provide 128-bit DNS services for .INFO. The TWO Proof-of-Concept
Registries, help to boot-strap .INFO using the "toy" 32-bit Internet. You may be pre-mature in
your concerns about the .INFO distribution of SLD names. In the end, the main goal will be to
take the "best-of-breed" [SLD].INFO names/owners and help them progress to using 128-bit DNS
services. Just as all TLDs do not make it, all [SLD].INFO names may not progress. You may not
want to judge a TLD by the early stages of its operations.

See...
http://www.Name-Space.com
...for .INFO names...

Jim Fleming
2002:[IPv4]:000X:03DB:...IPv8 is closer than you think...
http://www.ican.org/what's_new!!!.htm
http://www.iana.org/assignments/ipv4-address-space
http://www.ntia.doc.gov/ntiahome/domainname/130dftmail/unir.txt
3:219     INFO
===================================================

[1] 
INFO - NS Resource Records.
Click on any NS RR link below to do a ServerScan.

ANIC : AlterNIC : 160.79.129.192
Result = No Response

BORN : Business Oriented Root Network : 213.70.103.18
VueDig Results : Answer = 2 : Authority = 0 : Additional = 2. 
INFO. 2D IN NS TLD1.NOMINUM.COM.
INFO. 2D IN NS TLD2.NOMINUM.COM.

CINICS : Common Interest Network Information Center Society : 216.15.192.130
Result = No Response

iDNS : i-DNS.net International : 208.184.174.7
VueDig Results : Answer = 2 : Authority = 0 : Additional = 2. 
INFO. 2D IN NS TLD1.ULTRADNS.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS TLD2.ULTRADNS.NET.

LRS : Legacy Root Servers : 198.41.0.4
VueDig Results : Answer = 2 : Authority = 0 : Additional = 2. 
INFO. 2D IN NS TLD1.ULTRADNS.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS TLD2.ULTRADNS.NET.

NSpace : Name.Space : 209.48.2.11
VueDig Results : Answer = 10 : Authority = 0 : Additional = 10. 
INFO. 1D IN NS NS10.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 1D IN NS MEDIAFILTER.ORG.
INFO. 1D IN NS NS12.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 1D IN NS NS00.ROOT-ZONE.NET.
INFO. 1D IN NS ROOT8.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 1D IN NS NS1.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 1D IN NS NS11.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 1D IN NS ROOT3.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 1D IN NS C.TLD-SERVERS.NET.
INFO. 1D IN NS NS.AUTONO.NET.

Nnet : New.net Inc : 206.132.100.42
VueDig Results : Answer = 2 : Authority = 0 : Additional = 2. 
INFO. 1D IN NS TLD1.ULTRADNS.NET.
INFO. 1D IN NS TLD2.ULTRADNS.NET.

ONIC : The OpenNIC Project : 131.161.247.226
VueDig Results : Answer = 2 : Authority = 0 : Additional = 2. 
INFO. 2D IN NS tld2.ultradns.net.
INFO. 2D IN NS tld1.ultradns.net.

ORSC : Open Root Server Confederation : 199.166.24.1
VueDig Results : Answer = 10 : Authority = 0 : Additional = 10. 
INFO. 2D IN NS MEDIAFILTER.ORG.
INFO. 2D IN NS ROOT3.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS NS00.ROOT-ZONE.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS ROOT8.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS C.TLD-SERVERS.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS NS10.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS B.TLD-SERVERS.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS NS12.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS NS.AUTONO.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS NS1.AUTONO.NET.

ORSN : Open Root Server Network : 217.146.140.67
VueDig Results : Answer = 0 : Authority = 2 : Additional = 2. 
INFO. 2D IN NS TLD1.ULTRADNS.NET.
INFO. 2D IN NS TLD2.ULTRADNS.NET.

TINC : The Internet Namespace Cooperative : 64.6.65.10
Result = No Response

TPR : The PacificRoot : 204.107.129.2
VueDig Results : Answer = 3 : Authority = 0 : Additional = 3. 
INFO. 2D IN NS uk.universalroot.com.
INFO. 2D IN NS hk.universalroot.com.
INFO. 2D IN NS us.universalroot.com.

TUR : The Universal Registry : 66.38.220.12
Result = No Response
==============================================