Subject: [NEXTEL-1] Wireless News New Report Claims Wireless Spectrum Auction Hurting Economy.html

From: [email-masked]
Date: Sat, 26 Oct 2002 17:22:48 -0400

------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ---------------------~-->
Sell a Home with Ease!
http://us.click.yahoo.com/SrPZMC/kTmEAA/jd3IAA/61FxlB/TM
---------------------------------------------------------------------~->

Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ 

Explore:

NewsFactor Sites by Topic
Top Tech News
E-Business News
Wireless Industry News
Tech News Links
CRM Industry News
CRM Buyer Magazine (NEW)
Tech Opinions
Tech Innovation
Sci-Tech
Linux News Links
Free Newsfeeds
** Free Newsletters
-------------------------
NewsFactor Sites by Name:
-------------------------
NewsFactor.com
E-Commerce Times
Wireless NewsFactor
TechNewsWorld
NewsFactor Sci-Tech
CRM Daily
CRM Buyer Magazine
osOpinion
TechExtreme
Linux Insider
Free Newsfeeds
** Free Newsletters

Front Page

Archives

Mobile Devices

Networking

3G Wireless

Big Deals

Mobile Media

Wireless Web

Satellite

M-Commerce

Health & Safety

Stock Index

New Report Claims Wireless Spectrum Auction Hurting Economy

Send this Article

Print this Article

Talkback

Related Stories

By Joshua Piven

October 16, 2002

The study by the pro-business American Enterprise Institute and Criterion Economics outlines the declining performance of the wireless industry, but recent carrier actions in rolling out new advanced networks belie the author's claims.

Is the federal government's insistence that carriers meet their obligations for new licenses stifling wireless technology development? This is the contention of Verizon Wireless, the Cellular Telecommunications Industry Association, and other groups that are seeking to force the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to release deposits made for spectrum space promised to Nextwave Communications, now in bankruptcy.

The complex but important issue goes back to the wireless spectrum licenses held by the FCC and auctioned from 1998 - 2001. In 1998, Nextwave Communications placed the winning bid ($5 billion) for a license to develop portions of the wireless spectrum that had been unavailable to commercial entities.

When Nextwave declared bankruptcy, Verizon Wireless and several other carriers stepped in late in 2001 with bids of about $16 billion for the Nextwave licenses, which the FCC felt it could re-auction because Nextwave had defaulted on its required down payments. This re-auction is known as Auction 35. The FCC then collected billions in down payments from the new auction winners.

ADVERTISEMENT

<SCRIPT language='JavaScript1.1' SRC="http://ad.doubleclick.net/adj/N2614.newsfactornetwork./B1055698.2;abr=!ie;sz=336x280;ord=10356673725325?">
</SCRIPT>
<NOSCRIPT>
<A HREF="http://ad.doubleclick.net/jump/N2614.newsfactornetwork./B1055698.2;abr=!ie4;abr=!ie5;sz=336x280;ord=10356673725325?">
<IMG SRC="http://ad.doubleclick.net/ad/N2614.newsfactornetwork./B1055698.2;abr=!ie4;abr=!ie5;sz=336x280;ord=10356673725325?" BORDER=0 WIDTH=336 HEIGHT=280 ALT="Alt Text">Alt Text</A>
</NOSCRIPT>

Embroiled in Litigation

Fast forward to January of this year. With the FCC and Nextwave embroiled in litigation, Verizon asked the FCC to return its down payment, since the spectrum space has not been released to the winning bidders. The FCC returned 85% of the down payments ($2.8 billion) but has not agreed to release Verizon from its obligations under the contract signed by the winning bidders:

"The Commission will maintain the pending status of the applications for these licenses: This action will give the bidders access to the bulk of their money while at the same time preserving the results and integrity of Auction No. 35."

Now, Verizon has commissioned a study which states that the "FCC's conduct regarding Auction 35 is stifling the economic recovery of the struggling wireless industry, delaying the roll-out of new wireless services, and impeding wireless investment that would increase U.S. GDP by between $19 billion and $52 billion."

Declining Performance

The study, by Greg Sidak of the pro-business American Enterprise Institute and Criterion Economics, also states that despite its inability to produce licenses to Auction 35 winners since the auction concluded in 2001, the FCC has refused to cancel the re-auction results, even though it has no spectrum to give the winners. According to the FCC's decision: "Winning bidders from Auction 35 have been forced to treat their obligations as contingent liabilities without deriving any benefit from the underlying asset."

The study also outlines the declining performance of the wireless industry since the end of Auction 35. Between January 2001 and July 2002, according to Sidak, the market capitalization of telecommunications firms with large wireless divisions and wireless equipment manufacturers fell by more than $850 billion, or 65%. Over the same period, wireless service providers and wireless equipment manufacturers laid off nearly a quarter of a million workers.

Carrier Implosions

But the relationship between these developments and the Auction 35 licensing issue is tenuous. The entire economy, not just the telecommunications sector, has been contracting for 18 months. Further, much of the telecom decline can be attributed to the implosions of longhaul carriers like WorldCom and Qwest (among others), not to the wireless industry.

And even Verizon's own wireless actions belie Sidak's claims. The company rolled out the nation's first flat-fee, high-speed wireless Internet access network in June. It was followed by competitor Sprint (NYSE: FON) in August, and other companies are expected to join in shortly.

Known Risks

Verizon's argument is not without merit; if the FCC is not going to release the spectrum for development, it should release the company's funds when this becomes certain. But, as the FCC says, Verizon knew (or should have known) the risks when it signed its contracts.

By participating in the auction, the FCC says, "Verizon assumed a known risk of litigation-related delay and thus continues to be bound by the auction rules. Those rules require all bidders to pay their full bid in the event the commission is ultimately successful in its litigation and the licenses are issued."

Verizon may want its money back, but its reasons probably have more to do with its stock price than its wireless services.

© 2002 Computer Technology Review via ProQuest Information and Learning Company i/a/w ScreamingMedia, Inc. All rights reserved.
© 2002 NewsFactor Network. All rights reserved.

Talkback: Click here to add your comment about this story...

See Related Stories

FCC Proposes $5B Refund to Carriers in Spectrum Bid Dispute

(13-Sep-02)

NextWave and the 3G Spectrum Debacle

(31-May-02)

U.S. To Return $2.8B to Wireless Carriers

(28-Mar-02)

Supreme Court To Hear NextWave Case

(05-Mar-02)

Odds Against NextWave Survival in Spectrum Game

(20-Feb-02)

Verizon Wireless Sues U.S. for $1.7B Refund

(06-Feb-02)

Sponsored Links

Free Whitepaper: "Managing e-business integration challenges"

FREE Mobile Strategy Guide: Tapping the Power of the Mobile Enterprise.

Download a free trial of NetIQ WebTrends Reporting Center 5.0!

Reach Thousands of Internet Pros Everyday with NewsFactor Newsletters!

October 26, 2002

Why Hackers Don't Care About Wi-Fi
Full Story

Study: Consumers Slow To Upgrade Phones
Full Story

Can Lucent Find the Light?
Full Story

Wireless World Update 2002
Full Story

Wireless Game Time: On-Field Live Football
Full Story

Network Failure: The Corporate Kryptonite
Full Story

Bandits Dial Up Trouble
Full Story

Intel Pushes Wireless Networking
Full Story

PeopleSoft Announces Support for Pocket PC
Full Story

Microsoft Strikes $96M Deal To Buy Mapping Firm
Full Story

In-Flight Cell Phone Use Might Become a Reality
Full Story

The Next Generation of Smaller, Cheaper, Faster Mobile Chips
Full Story

A Cell Addict's Needs Sorely Misunderstood
Full Story

Agere Touts High-Speed Switching Chip
Full Story

Cheaper PDAs Tempt Buyers
Full Story

Survey Outlines Challenges for Wireless Carriers
Full Story

X-Ray Vision for G.I. Joe
Full Story

Sprint Launches New Data Service Price Plans
Full Story

Who Will Rule Cell Phone Sales in 2003?
Full Story

Motorola Snaps Losing Streak
Full Story

AMD Echoes Intel with Q3 Shortfall
Full Story

Lighting a Fire Under Mobile Phone Sales
Full Story

RIM Unveils Global BlackBerry Smartphones
Full Story

New Report Claims Wireless Spectrum Auction Hurting Economy
Full Story

Switching Cell Phone Providers - Why Bother?
Full Story

See more news

Get news by e-mail

Visit open forums

Wireless NewsFactor

Mobile Devices |
Wireless Web |
Networking |
3G Wireless

Satellite |
M-Commerce |
Big Deals |
Mobile Media |
Health & Safety |
Editorial Corrections

Other NewsFactor Network Sites

NewsFactor Portal |
E-Commerce Times |
TechNewsWorld |
Linux Insider |
Wireless NewsFactor

osOpinion |
TechExtreme |
CRMDaily |
CRM Buyer Magazine

FreeNewsFeed |
Free Newsletters

Business Development |
How To Contact Us |
About NewsFactor Network

How To Advertise |
Article Reprint Information

© 1998-2002 Triad Commerce Group, LLC. All rights reserved. See Terms of Use and Privacy notice.