Subject: [lamps] [Technical Errata Reported] RFC8649 (6421)

From: RFC Errata System <[email-masked]>
Date: Thu, 4 Feb 2021 16:30:12 -0800 (PST)

The following errata report has been submitted for RFC8649,
"Hash Of Root Key Certificate Extension".

--------------------------------------
You may review the report below and at:
https://www.rfc-editor.org/errata/eid6421

--------------------------------------
Type: Technical
Reported by: Daovone Rattanaphosy <[email-masked]>

Section: Rfc8649

Original Text
-------------
 ..'\ . .. . \.\ ~
.".. .. .... ,.
.. . .. - - ~
.P. .... ......
/
~
'
. \ ··f
': -'.!'••
Title: ARPA Network Functional Specifica.tions Author: G. Deloche
Insta.llation: University of Cali forni a at Los Angeles Date: 5 May 1969
Networ-k l'iorki.ng Group Request foT. Comnerrt: 8
 
 ,, ~ ':
,"
.r .
.
~~
 " 1""" "1-~ .
 
 II I
j-
n
"
,: :i
· ~, lLL if --
I _ U ~ L..,0 <:'-1:'" evv-. _ """ 'i: L. Jp...,.- , ,-,, ' .-\. f'( .;) ("
(
II I
I
1
 " "
;, "
L~""\
K
~Cu ~.A/\J_
z
~
Nl +wc'"1..K ')1 "r;:'~~l~
},-W1'~~ HC-v,J~
t _ Z. .
->
- ( , 0Mi)~'""cO'". ~~ \ ~ T"\~·\~'Y;)\.~
2._ \-RFCORIGINAL_TEXT ~l' l'fi\ ~0
r~i'h.'~J '~i,t WC~
c ~l~r ,
1.\o S\ [(~J )0 '\~)_
'J~Lc-. 0Cc..0 C·.'''---' ~
Co TV"\ F -r;S
~t e, ~~.)~~,"1 C...,.J/\ ,,1. l.~{)).v..-v_
[?(~ti,
  
  '",_. r<,
." ', !
~ ~ ~'.. .~ . _ .l.
..
I
;
~i
. ;!~.J(o
}'"'_c. y.~""'~ \i o <:. -:
(~JJ~)~ +2.;.~--{'g'ili~~'-~' )(
. ~\ ,~ , :i')~ ~J
II \.
l~'LJ ... r k
'1
::
;!
;:
'I
c. hHK ')~
I-\
-t,-.frlV)~";)\" ' "
,l--~K"",,~
t~i~~
~~t~ f\I f3.,L
,\oj
I -
~\I:>2: 2-2":
., {..~
tt i ~(Y~"1 .,'.
\
C-·1...L..J
t>-?'{' it"'"'/)
~t1(a f.tJ .l~( ....JiJ..t. , (J I
~ 1,_~~
-.' I . , " .......
- .," J
htc-L:J)'\~-.Y
(So. 'h-i) ..IJc>....;~
V) o-~
!~. ,
-1 t
~(7
b.J
-
~
.
r''·.(
r·:c~ ~-. cd
)r.>l. v5
1~I",?":'"':' .I
·
-...~
  
    I
I 'I
I
.~ ~ " .' ..'0\.
.+'':RFCORIGINAL_TEXT \
0\
0 J
t-: , A <:»
,_ .T. ~ 2.
1< :: , 1, " , ' ,
I',III1 ~ ft;Yr)4!>L(. . W <-J·r_
~ " '.t.,,c..H J. ~
. .... . . .:;
,- .;:
.
 ., '0 !\ !I
.;.
,!
i~
at ! ..! ,I
,I ;~ I I
r,,
y ; t s:
".. ... .
i,..
I
 i
,J
    
  .,
.1
'-( ?:) il
1 11 \ :r.
.t_j'A~.r-' .\' .
·l •
.' J:; ,I
·1
i :. ~y\-
i, o--li~ H-t
"
;
.'-. ~'". . . .,.' . .
(c"",J;;...,J
." ',: r.·
d~v)Cvu- j~V'·t"(o;t~-
-- _.-.---_._
."
\-f _\
~·~rL
wdh~ ~
~
O - r r 0 - (o.-+\~ ~~~~
. r-1~~\
t hC\." :\.D.Ii ,RFCORIGINAL_TEXT,..".,
t.--xA. J t ~
J SR\.
- \ W ~
h~o\. ~(1"Ccx1
( , ~ o X
( 1 ) . . ' 1 . . -
~
~
t~
t'""", V'n uLCl,1{
~\~
! t - " '
NLS> }
~
.?L....) J
'v ~ ~ H L
h ~ \ol
rCtrli.~
-\ ~ I\(J . " (>--r"t {-{v
I..-{
 .~ . ,;
,k ~~(~ (~{'\~... }~od~c:.~ r)k.~·_·Lt
'": II
;i~rL ;,
:j \J..,.~-
r; • , {~"~"'.~ . -
.... ( ; I'
w~ ~t.
~. 1r'k...~ rtv_.J. .
  I ',.•_.••.I .J1 '...i .1l.. •• .I.
J..A
f#>0••• 1....:/
 
  ,,.
.,Jr', ': I
'.
• • • • • •:
. I •
" !" .t
I! i! il
il
:;
:1
II
.1 I
ihh J~~
I'
i' 1!
~~.U:~ lIo~I~O:Y- H-~a.tL;'"'d--
'1 " I.
.\ ~,!,
I II 11
•'I \ k
( N C )~
t,~ 'i\f"NM
( - 1 4 o f , " " , / ~L, K " , r - -
(o-~'I"~ ~o.r - H~~ ~~od~~"
..
~~'lr{
1J{'"
--Jt" "l'~~ 1
,
i
"
It.
.i :~
:
/0" l'\-J
L ")0 (..,-I~. Ih
J
~"C'I"'~~ :: r.~"",)
~j.vk, (.~o,..--rJ
1/""
i;, il ~
I
'1 .:~ 'I
I
'-r~.
#~A l · ; O ' ¥:
~ t'
er-\ lp(~ '(~lj)-)C:
, ~Iu.b~~.) .,It
~O~}( ; :~~ He--~
t}~' '.
.. p\~wvf~ ,
I;
.i !!
;~
l
f:> f~K. ' ~tLCto"
'
1 h.t 1h.t
\~.
-r. \I 0 ~I
(10 ~ ....aCu·J~"'4 ,..I
")1.\ }tMJ\)~'1
i
- - - - , - -  \h I'"d"-~V)
1T,!.-t. l'. ut
' 'l.~ ./\
: ', ~ t l : ' ;
i:
: r-e: t
 rc-r~ ~ t~1'CI.NY)
\o.-,dWIv\.t 'v~
v..~"
~j
;f ~ f
./.
" "",)t:: I e-
   
  .'
\\ ' "'-
1,.\'",\k -\cr:
~:Jt.< 't cev...v..J;.'D-vj I...,
~. l
10 H0 ~T( X ) .(.
~ _ ~Oj . ~
S-I".-....Ao....J
~,
"T~: ~,otL \.RFCORIGINAL_TEXTs,("
~"c"'h.k'> \'
'I I"'j (~~! ~L ~(ha:_, -:: '.. .;
"\ .,
I
L
L,V\.t·' t~V
:' .;
;j
'! .".
!:
".' .~
,.. .. .
Joyl, _~~~'-":~:
~ '~(T(O.! (~-'V.-W
..,. , '.,
. -:.:t .. .,1
"" Lot t~~r' , ir q-,J.
, T t to
t......J
''"
') ,1",-,-_
* 'SJ;,_t ~
., "
'.N1
S'IJyY~ 0,J,':{ ,~~...
fl?$.-r (xl_
~y.,\.t,~k,J.
~~\,(>lL.t
i,.;
l-;£'!(~<;t:) b".i "cr ; .
f'IL.'S c.J sP-\'_ -:i
.. ::
r _"Wc. ..l , ' ,~,
(
. • r ...... ~
,'. ; : :
' : ; :
...... ()
, y '~l Q...,u~I",.,.' ,
~,~ :
~~~ . ~I -. .'\
.:.
,
  
   I
I
I I
c (~ ~, ~ /
i.': ··t·:;'.: -r'r':""' .1 h~ .~ l'l... .,t.......t~ ",,):t.:"". r.')\....,...\'~ ; ..-
(~~
. ..........." - -'- ' .....~
p+ ~ ..
.
, 8 · . 0 ~ l .
.~
~
. ' .' (
~
..." ~-:
.
\.._
' U - . . . -. Y l . t " . t 0
. . .
':~:
.
.~
.'..p). .C~~it:~.."G-_.~~~ *.J.~.·h.·r.;t-_·.t:~.\<.. -\.0":_ .. ~o~ .HO~T
_
. :1\v f"'..,jl.v;Jd '~J. H
,id 'e":! .:..:~.,.
~...~.J" _.;~+~+ 0.....
. ..\':~'t~'\.~ ., ~ ~.., ( .. ........... •
•_....c-.
._.
" " "
.
t
... _
l~~ ~ .t:t ( ~·bl'0 - t(
,I-:k'~ \ I)~..?
-
.....-...:lilII
.~J", (~~~et·~ ~c-.J;
t~ 1- \Jc1,'A-td.~~ \r.v.'1t~tt
o,
. ~.l 'YJ.-\.-J4
s
t
.j~
_',.. k
0 . - , ('- -r' ~ ~ ~
~ ~ko, .
~
i
J~~~ .'.'
'1."'-'-,
t:",K to-
vc t,
r:
t'\.o
~(0_ r~-e.-.~
i,
,'",
_'t.t ,;\"c.JJ ~"+b )1..•t-.bl;".Sl)\,;~i"
.
c.
~'
.I
. :-: '.' .... . ... . '. ..... -
eaI<§ tk
Sf<,l:_ ,k Ih' -J·'-kIi~~i
t:~k e.j ........n·r•. .\r., c"<A.
. :J .:.
q-~"",
~ _~\'< ~,r-~
s-
i . ; K I 1 l ' L < \ " H'
.
~-'',i ._..,:.~~.
~
i
.
·
.
'
 7.(' Jk ~ ~
I· .!
t;....1 . ~v· . · .~ I, ,-~'<" ., ,~~ . W~··< ~
.~
h t L.
l.~;~ ~A
to
·· ,. ~<.0 . K
.' }'.AJ....1. -: (H~ ~ ,=<i~lj.
. "~jJht \}~~J. f~ _~'v~ .b~ ~~~ct_~.:·;;: . ~ .~\O~.,. . v-...J~Qt·c~~ ¥v~~ _ . , " :; , ..
_ .. \~~4on;~ :tJ~~.~-y~ (~~t~'.;~ o'1- ",.fo:...~~ ?"b~-t .{.I\H ;1 ,l.-.oz:&;1.~
o.~~cb-J ~ c.({..~,/~r~J:_ t
.
"_"-)' .
  j
-t'. ,"_ '." ..\~,
I,• L~...t(!.~L&-n
\'.IJ .1/ ..'~l r-~-.'(0-2'v.-, c-~~~;'~'_ "
 . r'" ~ ~
v-;.<\
~~~t; ;k ,". ,.,... .. .
'J
t (;.y.~t·"Wt':.:.;.: .. ,',.:; ~
   
    .~ ., ~..-
" ..,'.
.-.- ..-..---- . ... .
. .~. ' ... . {-.....' ..
r.:° . ! ", o .
:..\°;0
. e -.. I
~
':-, ~;
... .-
...
  ---
()
.
,
": :-
;- . ~: :
. 0"': '; 1;1:~;.-
·i .-
~.'
...
.L~k c.. rAq1~'~'O
.. ;"
    
   .. , j
,i .j I
'! .~ ,I
. •_•..J _
I ,!
~~
,
,
j
I
~
'~, . I'
" '~ - '
,~
j.
,.. !::
r-:+-iil'
~
.- ..
. .,,«...
.'.l ;'
~,
I·> ,:.J .r :
.. I.
- : ' 1" . i ·1I,
,r
. ·1....·
..
_ . .1 " ;1'
1' .
-'-I .,i to ".t
I
'1 L "l
.,
,
II• • •• • 1
'1
.... ..,--"I. .r' !!j
., t
T :'-;
-I
,~
..,.... - ,
I
..I
~,
III ,f
~ ,.-+ ,
I
1- ..;.
t ' -i ' - -" -;
t - 1" ' ~tjt~i
:. ,t  to ~ ... l'
..t'"r". 0 ,I
";
H.1 :r-.--r. i '
W .; ," " tI.
..
t· : ....j- i
"
.~
--t" :
.. I' I
I
i " ···f
1:!
~.
~"+"j I ,I!
:I'I ,,
y...,1--i '. I ,,' I ,
.. _i
Li.~1~~.i~ . .
t.<)-t-"l'
f .,...;...._J...r. 1..i
-1
,!
i. ,I
i_~ I
, ,I •_•••_••••• __••_a•
~_.. ~. ~.. ..P ~9 i; flAt'\ t::
I .,;
~,~...:. ..
J•
; ' .. t
tI,.r•.•1 • j-1'I",i.
,~ ,
+I. IP: ...
- ..
'I"7' . .... T ~RMI ~JAL
I
I
.'\-\~. .~i
-e.-l!"R t.L,~~
t. .
t .: .
" !,i'
,
r..
~.
·I'!'
I i-: ri
, t~.~',h\ :,~i.-
,. ·r
r i;
!.. .
r .J .!.
~.
i
...
. ..~
'.j
.. r.
..J ..t ,.I
.
.\ '.
-..,- .
~ ..
.,
",  i
"r . ' '' ,
..
.i -_.
t .. •
1'1 .
'
~
j
.~~ ~ "~ :iII.
!...j. 1!
I
~ Jl
i, .
r
,I ,
.
~ ~.,
.;
~
 ~•••J.-. I
-.. ..!
; !r{(f\.Ns.,M.
.l-\f\~DL.f ~
I -- -~~---' -. ..~ ,\"
'f"-~~ I I
t .;.:'
 ~
~
.'
;}'~~~'
....
..
I
~;";;".
 ~
....1
,
~
~.
I
,. ·.,.,. ·..t·-+ ..
!
.I-+~.L. j,---";lOi~V-_+---+
I_,
,
J,:
•. ! . i
I. • 1·1
~
,..
: " • • 1 '~ "
"
~.~
·'t'
  I . '.
.:;..
,', r;
-, . .
lI
-r--.•.t. .t.-t ./
~
.
. '..~
"! ~ .....
,_l.,\ ,.
•T
   
   -. ' "
! .
I. --i--- _, _ _ -i.-.-
!...i I
(€ i~_.;._..: tI,•
J-.;- ..~I'·--~·~·• . I
•,.,..-1
j
j. .•;
I.
·
.!.
;
.·, .
.;..,..~ 1_.1
•. t-. -4·..-4-.--1.._.,
: :':
.~ . Ii.
;..r'
....
i.; ..,,;....r·....- · ..+
~
'a :
~
~.••~:
.
.r .,
!:
.
.~
'~-
.
~ i : +-.
' 1' ••i'II
TetT
I
.
;
J' "r.....:
_~
. . .... --+ .. '"7 " - ' - .. . - . .:i!
··4 .. ~ ,
i:I1; .:.
....;... ,._-i-..
·J1:··:·::1·.:~J·:r~
i
-!' -,...~.- -....~..-!-.---i"---+-o.,o-.
: ..t
• Ii .••.••• -4. 1-v-. - '- _.. ....:.---l..--~_..;
ii r'-'"~....:.
. _._ .L
.i. ...•,-_.
I
I
.'
+- ...~ .'
j. ..j."1'';"0:" r""
i.~''! ..; 
I
I"
'
..• f;
" t . " - : . - ~, ,' • . I .
-.r..\.~:~\.,') ,J,...•::... ;~ • .•.. t'
,. ..~_.
;. . :
-.\..rI·~ 1Jtl-Lr;.HoST
r
,1
i
'" ~•.! 1-..
1. •. .'..··r--of' .t.-.'r J.
i· "~ •t· •.••;•.. 1I
j . .
... . ·'w
L-
........
i, ....-..
f" !
.)
f· ..r
~
r·' . iI
. .!.. . ....._..... I
.f· .
i .\
.r'
,~
.:
1
:
:.
.
.! . .
I
'-r .. I
:
~,
1. ~I I I
L
r
... . I.
I
!
::-' ~ ~ .,J...
,, I
•t i-.. t o .
 ~.
;
... ...
I .... r
.
: I . .,
:'
 ..! ..,.
i' T
. t···
I ,·.
~
..
t!I
I
· 1.. ...•. I
I
1· ,~. .~
I
 ..•.... .!

Corrected Text
--------------
O

Notes
-----
O

Instructions:
-------------
This erratum is currently posted as "Reported". If necessary, please
use "Reply All" to discuss whether it should be verified or
rejected. When a decision is reached, the verifying party  
can log in to change the status and edit the report, if necessary. 

--------------------------------------
RFC8649 (draft-ietf-lamps-hash-of-root-key-cert-extn-07)
--------------------------------------
Title               : Hash Of Root Key Certificate Extension
Publication Date    : August 2019
Author(s)           : R. Housley
Category            : INFORMATIONAL
Source              : Limited Additional Mechanisms for PKIX and SMIME
Area                : Security
Stream              : IETF
Verifying Party     : IESG

---

From: Russ Housley <[email-masked]>
Date: Fri, 5 Feb 2021 08:27:30 -0500

This looks like noise to me.

> On Feb 4, 2021, at 7:30 PM, RFC Errata System <[email-masked]> wrote:
>

---

From: Megan Ferguson <[email-masked]>
Date: Mon, 8 Feb 2021 10:06:09 -0500

Thanks, Russ.

This report has been deleted.

RFC Editor/mf